时间:2024-09-21 21:59:19 来源:网络整理 编辑:行业动态
Popular in News & Politics The One Way Trump Could Surprise Us Now
Shortly after Wisconsin voters replaced Republican Gov. Scott Walker with Democrat Tony Evers in 2018, GOP lawmakers scrambled to strip the incoming governor of power. In a special session, Republicans revoked Evers’ ability to make dozens of appointments throughout the executive branch, reducing his authority over state commissions. They hobbled incoming Democratic Attorney General Josh Kaul’s ability to represent the state in litigation. And they slashed early voting across the state in violation of a federal court order. Walker approved the power grab weeks before leaving office.
On Thursday, Circuit Judge Richard G. Niess blocked every single law the Republican legislature passed in late 2018. In his ruling, Niess held that the session was convened in violation of the state constitution, rendering the bills it produced unlawful and void. The decision vacates 82 of Walker’s last-minute appointments, restores Evers’ oversight over the executive branch, and allows Kaul to represent Wisconsin in court. But Republicans are certain to appeal the decision, where a 4–3 conservative majority may well reverse it.
*Wisconsin Republicans’ lame-duck legislative coup is, by now, a familiar story. Faced with a Democratic governor, GOP legislators decided to hobble the executive branch they’d spent years empowering under Walker. They passed a fusillade of laws that allowed Walker to make midnight appointments and barred Evers’ control over multiple state commissions. These measures transferred appointment power from the governor to the state Assembly, allowing legislators to appoint members to the Department of Corrections, the Department of Transportation, the Group Insurance Board (which oversees state benefits), the Department of Administration (which creates the state budget), and more. They also curbed executive agencies’ ability to pass regulations regarding taxes, education, elections, and health care.
AdvertisementGOP lawmakers also took aim at Kaul’s office, abolishing the Office of the Solicitor General and restricting Kaul’s involvement in a lawsuit brought by and against Wisconsin. Historically, the attorney general represents the state in litigation, but the new laws authorized legislative leadership to defend state laws—using private lawyers paid for by taxpayers—instead. They also forbade the attorney general from settling or withdrawing from litigation without legislative consent. This rule was designed to maintain Wisconsin’s participation in a lawsuit to kneecap the Affordable Care Act. (An additional measure curtailing early voting has already been blocked by a federal court.)
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement The legislature requires express permission from either a statute or the governor to call a special session. It received neither.Evers, along with a group of civil rights advocates, filed suit in state court, alleging that the special session—and, by extension, the legislation it produced—was illegal. Niess agreed in a sharply worded opinion. Before statehood, Niess explained, colonists had “very real grievances” with “irregular legislative sessions.” To “constrain legislative overreach and safeguard the people’s liberty from irregular, capricious, precipitous, and unpredictable meetings of the Legislature,” the framers of the Wisconsin constitution adopted “a check on the Legislature’s otherwise unfettered discretion.” Under that constitution, the Assembly may only meet “at such time as shall be provided” by statute, or “unless convened by the governor in special session.”
AdvertisementBut no statute permitted the Assembly to meet in December 2018. And “for whatever reason,” Walker failed to “exercise his constitutional authority to call a special session.” Rather, a majority of two legislative committees voted to convene the full Assembly. In total, just eight lawmakers—five representatives and three senators, all Republicans—voted to convene the December special session. The legislature then passed three sweeping bills and appointed Walker’s 82 midnight appointments.
To justify their maneuver, GOP legislators cite a statute that allows the legislature to develop a “work schedule” for its own session. By convening the Assembly, Republicans argue, lawmakers merely exercised their authority to modify their “work schedule,” calling back legislators for unfinished business. Niess disagreed. This “coiled reasoning,” he wrote, cannot mask the fact the legislature convened a session “not at a time set by law,” but “by just a few legislators on short notice.” Republicans cannot short-circuit the constitution by “creat[ing] its own authority to meet … any time at all.” The legislature requires express permission from either a statute or the governor to call a special session. It received neither, and so the actions it took ran afoul of the constitution.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementNiess’ decision is hard to quibble with, but the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s current far-right majority will probably overturn it—if it gets the chance. In April, Wisconsin voters will replace an outgoing Democratic justice with either Brian Hagedorn, a controversial conservative, or Lisa Neubauer, a progressive. If Neubauer wins, the court’s 4–3 conservative majority will remain—though a Republican justice’s seat is up in 2020, giving Democrats a chance to finally flip the court.* Unless Evers can delay the appeal until after the 2020 election, which is unlikely, the current GOP majority seems poised to reverse Niess.
Correction, March 21, 2019: This article originally misstated that the April 2019 Wisconsin Supreme Court election could give Democratic justices a majority. That opportunity will not arise until the 2020 election.
Tweet Share Share Comment热浪来袭 科学应对防中暑2024-09-21 21:37
青啤、肯德基联合促销送出新春贺礼2024-09-21 21:12
近1.8亿株!广东各地做好春季植树造林苗木准备2024-09-21 21:08
芦山县森林公安局开展冬季野生动物保护工作2024-09-21 20:41
“新丰味”喜获中国首届县域品牌擂台赛十大营销创新品牌2024-09-21 20:20
科普链接:雅安动植物基因库之长尾鸭2024-09-21 19:56
“我的甘薯就是第一!”2024陆丰薯王出炉!2024-09-21 19:55
涓浗宸ュ晢閾惰闈掑矝榛勫矝鏀鍥㈠鎴愬姛涓惧姙鈥滄儏瀹氳タ娴峰哺锛屾垜浠湪涓€璧封€?017閾朵紒闈掑勾鑱旇皧浼歘涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝2024-09-21 19:52
The Best AMD Ryzen Gaming Laptops (So Far)2024-09-21 19:46
2020年青岛全市电子商务交易额将突破1万亿元2024-09-21 19:30
18 Places for Epic Outdoor Adventure Across Colorado2024-09-21 21:09
青岛制造!我国首款时速160公里城际动车组开跑2024-09-21 21:07
我市林业审批大提速 七成以上事项实现“零跑腿”2024-09-21 21:04
青岛联通精雕细琢打造校园精品网络2024-09-21 21:02
Anatomy of a Keyboard2024-09-21 21:01
搭建交流平台 共促教育发展2024-09-21 20:46
预见2024:谈谈农牧大佬的新年献词2024-09-21 20:44
拒绝侥幸 杜绝酒驾从我做起2024-09-21 20:43
水产品占“四席”!广州南沙十个农产品上榜“国字号”2024-09-21 20:24
科普链接:雅安动植物基因库之长尾鸭2024-09-21 19:43