您的当前位置:首页 > 资讯 > The ad industry is still hilariously corrupt, report says 正文
时间:2024-09-21 22:57:56 来源:网络整理 编辑:资讯
Ad agencies are using smoke-and-mirror tricks to drive up production costs on their clients' dime, a
Ad agencies are using smoke-and-mirror tricks to drive up production costs on their clients' dime, according to a new report from an advertiser trade group.
The Association of National Advertisers, which reps big brands like Procter & Gamble, General Motors, and Walmart, found that advertising giants have been known to route lucrative contracts for production and post-production work on commercials to their own in-house shops. This is done through deceptive--and illegal--means like enlisting other agencies to rig the bidding process or disguising their ownership of the firms, the report claims.
SEE ALSO:Why American ad agencies are being accused of having secret agendasThe accusation adds to a growing sense among advertisers--i.e. the parties that foot the bill for all this clandestine maneuvering--that Madison Avenue is using shady business practices to run up their tabs.
It's also caught the attention of federal regulators. The Wall Street Journalreported in December that the Justice Department has opened a probe into these production schemes, which violate competition laws meant to keep markets on a level playing field.
Heading up the investigation is antitrust lawyer Rebecca Meiklejohn, who famously sent a handful of ad execs to jail for similar charges in 2004.
Suffice to say, these are some weighty allegations. But they're also not all that novel. Such dealings have long been something of an open secret in the industry, according to the report's author, ANA vice president Bill Duggan.
"We've been hearing rumblings of this activity for several years now," Duggan said. "It was a long road to get here, and by the time we got here, there was just a lot of evidence."
The study comes on the heels of another bombshell transparency report from the ANA last summer that outlined nebulous rebate schemes through which agencies collude with firms that buy ad placements and media companies in ways that aren't necessarily in the best interest of clients.
Duggan says the group first began collecting evidence on the production rigging while interviewing various industry professionals for that previous research. In addition to those primary sources, the most recent 30-page report is based on the testimonies of a dozen experts on various parts of industry sausage-making, all but one of whom agreed that yeah, transparency seems to be a pretty big problem (the last expert said he had only secondhand knowledge).
"Source after source--or rather...subject matter expert after subject matter expert--has suggested that these things have been going on," Duggan said.
The ANA declined to name any specific bad actors.
Over the past few decades, the global ad industry has been largely folded into six giant holding companies--a process that was expedited by the looming threat of Silicon Valley disruption.
Those behemoths now control firms operating at every level of the advertising assembly line--from creative shops to media buyers to production companies and, in some cases, even media outlets.
In the traditional way of doing things, these smaller companies are supposed to compete for each other's business in order to ensure the best deal for clients. But it's not hard to see how conglomerate entanglements might make for a conflict of interest.
That situation along with chaos caused by the industry's bumpy transition to a digital-first world have led to a situation where advertisers and agencies trust one another less than ever. Record numbers of marketers have put their agencies under review in the past couple years--a process in which an advertiser decides whether or not it wants to fire them. Agency-of-record deals, in which one firm handles all of a client's business are becoming increasingly rare.
Agency trade group 4A's came out in fierce opposition to the rebates report, but their reaction to the latest finding seemed a bit more muted. In a statement to Adweek, it simply said it “condemns any activity or business practice that is unethical or, of course, illegal.”
The group didn't immediately respond to a request for clarification.
Against All Odds: How Netflix Made It2024-09-21 22:41
Swiping is here to turn the YouTube app into ultimate time2024-09-21 22:37
N. Korea to hold ruling party plenary meeting on agriculture this month2024-09-21 22:14
LG is experimenting with rollable smartphones2024-09-21 21:40
The Measurers2024-09-21 21:25
'Fortnite' vulnerability put millions of accounts at risk2024-09-21 21:13
NK science commission's 2023 research to focus on agriculture, key industries2024-09-21 21:12
竹马220千伏输变电工程获省发改委核准2024-09-21 21:12
21 Caves That Offer Otherworldly Experiences2024-09-21 21:01
Fury forecasts 'biggest year of career'2024-09-21 20:41
Abrar Ahmed returns as Pakistan names squad for second Test against Bangladesh2024-09-21 22:45
DuckDuckGo's private searches will pull up Apple Maps results2024-09-21 22:36
雅电集团多项措施保障电网安全运行2024-09-21 22:20
Park calls for mutually beneficial partnership with OECD2024-09-21 22:10
Number of COVID2024-09-21 22:07
Chief nuke envoys of S. Korea, US, Japan criticize NK push to bolster 'self2024-09-21 21:50
Japanese skaters dominate Grand Prix final2024-09-21 21:36
LG is experimenting with rollable smartphones2024-09-21 21:25
Who is the Dark Wizard in 'The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power' Season 2?2024-09-21 21:12
[Graphic News] Financial workers feel most threatened by AI2024-09-21 20:13