您的当前位置:首页 > 行业动态 > Alito denies Pennsylvania Republicans‘ request to preserve partisan gerrymander. 正文
时间:2024-09-22 12:41:23 来源:网络整理 编辑:行业动态
On Monday, Justice Samuel Alito rejected Pennsylvania Republicans’ last-ditch effort to preserve the
On Monday, Justice Samuel Alito rejected Pennsylvania Republicans’ last-ditch effort to preserve the partisan gerrymander of their state’s congressional map. The justice’s decision effectively ensures that Pennsylvania’s 2018 congressional elections will be held under a much fairer map, giving Democrats an opportunity to win several more seats in the state. In fact, the dissolution of Pennsylvania’s gerrymander gives Democrats a significantly better shot at winning control of the House of Representatives in November.
SCOTUS intervention in the Pennsylvania redistricting litigation was always unlikely. When the Pennsylvania Supreme Court invalidated the current map on Jan. 22, it did so exclusively under the Pennsylvania Constitution. The U.S. Supreme Court cannot overrule a state supreme court on a question of state law; it may only step in when a state law or court order violates the federal Constitution. Republican legislative leaders had argued that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decision ran afoul of the federal Constitution’s Elections Clause, which allows state legislatures to prescribe “the times, places and manner of holding [congressional] elections.” Legislators asserted that their state Supreme Court had unlawfully stripped them of their constitutional prerogative to draw congressional maps.
But this argument is plainly untenable for two reasons. First, the U.S. Supreme Court held in 2015 that the Elections Clause does not grant state legislatures exclusiveredistricting power. Indeed, the court found that citizens could prohibit their state legislature from redistricting altogether and direct an independent commission to draw congressional maps instead. If a legislature can be deprived of all redistricting power, surely it can also be compelled to draw districts that comport with the state constitution.
Second, the GOP legislators’ position would bar courts from reviewing the legality of anycongressional gerrymander. Under their argument, no court could strike down a gerrymander, partisan or otherwise, or draw remedial maps to remedy constitutional flaws. Courts are not legislatures, after all, so judges would have no authority to intercede in gerrymandering disputes. No justice, not even Clarence Thomas, has ever held that legislative redistricting is insulated from judicial review.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementAlito’s dismissal of Pennsylvania Republicans’ appeal, then, was pretty much inevitable—although the justice appears to have given it more consideration than it deserved. (Alito reviews emergency appeals out of Pennsylvania; he dismissed this appeal without referring it to the full court, though he did order a response from voting rights advocates.) Monday’s decision was also excellent news for Democrats, who were hobbled by the GOP-drawn map. Registered Democrats significantly outnumber registered Republicans in Pennsylvania, yet Republicans won 13 out of 18 congressional districts in 2016. The Associated Press found that the gerrymander likely gave Republicans at least three extra House seats.
Monday’s dismissal is especially bad news for one Republican in particular: Pennsylvania Senate President pro tempore Joseph Scarnati. Last Wednesday, Scarnati declared that he would defy a Pennsylvania Supreme Court order requesting data to help it commission a nonpartisan map. The legislator insisted that SCOTUS would soon reverse the state Supreme Court. Now that it has refused to do so, Scarnati is out of options: He must turn over the data or risk being held in contempt of court. Pennsylvania’s midterm elections will be held in much fairer districts, whether Republicans like it or not.
Tweet Share Share CommentHow much will PCB's Champions Cup mentors be paid?2024-09-22 12:24
Best Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 deal: Get up to $250 trade2024-09-22 12:14
12 Celebrations Where Fire and Fireworks Reign Supreme2024-09-22 11:51
Cyber Monday fitness deals 2023: Fitbit, NordicTrack, Garmin, more2024-09-22 11:27
Keurig K Mini deal — get $30 off at Target2024-09-22 11:10
15 Places Every Tea2024-09-22 10:58
A wolf left its irradiated Chernobyl home. What happens if it mates?2024-09-22 10:54
志愿服务扎实开展 社会风气持续向好2024-09-22 10:49
I went to an offline dating event for singles. Here's how it went.2024-09-22 10:36
Bog Butter, Ancient Beef, and Other Remarkably Old Foods on Display in Museums2024-09-22 10:11
Top 10 Tech Pranks2024-09-22 12:25
Moroccan daughter of Korean War veteran honors father's legacy2024-09-22 12:20
24 of America's Best Preserved Ghost Towns2024-09-22 12:19
23 Places to Relive the Cold War2024-09-22 12:14
U.S. Senators call on FTC to investigate the security of drivers' data2024-09-22 11:18
我市召开市乡镇行政区划和村级建制调整改革“后半篇”文章专项工作领导小组会议2024-09-22 11:13
Roblox will soon let players make calls from inside the game2024-09-22 10:30
加强森林防火教育 提高师生安全意识2024-09-22 10:04
Apple's iPhone 17 will come with a huge RAM upgrade, report claims2024-09-22 10:03
15 Places Every Tea2024-09-22 10:01